Terry's Impossibility

St. John's Law Review

Most legal theory suffers from a tendency to underestimate the magnitude and im-portance of error costs. That tendency is a particular problem when it comes to legal regulation of street-level policing. Law enforcement and the law that regulates it does indeed function best when seen, as they should be, as "grown" rather than "made." And a great deal of legal theory instead treats policing and Fourth Amendment law as "made" systems. Most of what we would like that law to accomplish is impossible; the necessary legal judgments cannot be made with even a decent degree of accuracy. When regulating street policing, we are living in a land of bad choices.

Link to Work